ChatGPT vs. Google AI Shopping: The Merchant Strategy Guide for 2025

The AI Shopping War Nobody's Talking About

Two AI shopping giants launched within 120 days of each other. Both promise to transform how customers discover and buy products. Both are rolling out globally right now.

But here's the paradox that's confusing every merchant: Google AI Mode has 50 billion product listings but zero conversational training. ChatGPT has 700 million weekly users but no shopping DNA.

Which platform should you optimize for first?

The answer isn't "pick one." It's "understand both and optimize strategically." Because merchants who figure this out in the next 3-6 months will establish AI visibility before the rush. Those who don't will spend 2026 playing catch-up.

Here's the data-driven decision framework.

---

Two Platforms, Two Approaches

Google AI Mode launched at Google I/O in May 2025 and expanded globally throughout October. It brings conversational shopping to Google's massive ecosystem: 50+ billion products in the Shopping Graph, 1 billion daily shopping queries, and 25 billion monthly Lens searches.

The experience combines Gemini AI with Google's shopping infrastructure. Users ask questions in AI Mode, get visual product recommendations, and can use features like virtual try-on for apparel. Results include both paid (Performance Max) and organic listings.

ChatGPT Instant Checkout launched September 29, 2025, powered by the Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP). It brings in-chat purchasing to 700 million weekly ChatGPT users. Shoppers ask for product recommendations, get curated suggestions, and complete purchases without leaving the conversation.

Currently live for US-based Etsy sellers. Over 1 million Shopify merchants coming soon. PayPal announced support in October, bringing tens of millions more merchants into the ecosystem by 2026.

The critical window: Both platforms are in early adoption phase. ChatGPT Shopping is 6 weeks old. Google AI Mode is expanding to new countries monthly. The first-mover advantage window is open right now.

How They Compare

Factor	Google AI Mode	ChatGPT Shopping
User Base	100M+ monthly active users (pre-expansion), 1B daily shopping queries	700M weekly users
Product Catalog	50+ billion listings (Shopping Graph)	Growing base (Etsy live, Shopify launching)
Discovery Style	Query-based with AI summaries and visual browsing	Conversational recommendations in chat
Shopping Behavior	Inspiration/browsing shopping	Research/decision shopping
Checkout	Redirect to merchant site	Instant in-chat via Stripe
Paid Opportunities	YES - Performance Max campaigns	NO - Organic only (for now)
Geographic Reach	200+ countries and territories	US only (expanding)
Merchant Requirements	Google Merchant Center + Product Feed optimization	Structured data + ACP integration
Time to Visibility	Faster (existing feed infrastructure)	Slower (new protocol, manual review)
Optimization Familiarity	HIGH - Most merchants know Google Shopping	LOW - New learning curve for ACP

The User Intent Difference

Google AI Mode users: Browsing, exploring, getting inspired. They often know what category they want (e.g., "hiking boots") but need help narrowing options. Visual browsing matters. Comparison shopping is common.

ChatGPT users: Researching specific problems, seeking explanations, making considered decisions. They often describe use cases (e.g., "I need boots for winter hiking in Colorado") and want conversational guidance. Detail and context matter.

The Ranking Algorithm Difference

Google AI Mode prioritizes:

• Product feed quality (titles, descriptions, images)
• Merchant Center performance metrics
• Price competitiveness
• Review ratings and quantity
• Image quality (especially for visual try-on)
• Ad spend (for Performance Max placements)

ChatGPT Shopping prioritizes:

• Product relevance to conversational query
• Structured data completeness
• Bing indexing quality
• Product description detail
• Merchant reviews and reputation
• Instant Checkout availability (ranking boost)

Different algorithms mean different optimization strategies.

Which Platform First?

Most merchants are asking the wrong question: "ChatGPT or Google?"

The right question: "Which platform matches my product type and customer journey - and how do I optimize for both?"

Prioritize Google AI Mode If:

✅ You already have Google Merchant Center set up - Leverage existing infrastructure. Optimization takes 1-2 hours vs. 4-8 hours for ChatGPT from scratch.

✅ You sell visual products - Fashion, home decor, accessories. Google's virtual try-on and visual browsing features give you advantage. Customers shop with their eyes.

✅ You want paid visibility options - Performance Max campaigns let you buy visibility while optimizing organically. ChatGPT is organic-only currently.

✅ You need global reach - 200+ countries now vs. US-only for ChatGPT. If your customers are international, Google wins on reach.

✅ You have large catalog (1,000+ SKUs) - Google's Shopping Graph handles scale better. Feed-based optimization is more efficient for large inventories.

✅ You're optimizing for browsing behavior - Customers who explore categories, compare multiple options, and make visual decisions.

Prioritize ChatGPT Shopping If:

✅ You sell complex products - Tech, B2B equipment, specialized tools. Products that need explanation benefit from conversational context.

✅ You have detailed product knowledge - Specs, use cases, comparisons. ChatGPT surfaces products when users ask detailed questions.

✅ Your customers research extensively - High-consideration purchases. ChatGPT users are often deep in research phase, closer to purchase decision.

✅ You're US-focused - For now. Geographic expansion coming, but current opportunity is US market.

✅ You want early AI positioning - First-mover advantage window is WIDE OPEN. Low competition, high visibility potential for early adopters.

✅ You're optimizing for decision-making behavior - Customers who ask questions, compare tradeoffs, and want guidance.

The Smart Strategy: Both Platforms, Different Tactics

Here's what early winners are doing: Optimize for both platforms, but with different product strategies.

Google AI Mode: Lead with your most visual, browsing-friendly products. Fashion, home goods, gifts. Products where image quality and visual presentation drive decisions.

ChatGPT Shopping: Lead with your most explanation-heavy products. Technical items, specialized tools, products with use case complexity.

Total time investment: 6-8 hours for dual optimization. That's the barrier to entry most competitors won't clear in the next 3 months.

Dual Platform Optimization

Google AI Mode Quick Wins (1-2 hours)

1. Audit Your Product Feed (15 minutes)

Log into Google Merchant Center. Check for:

• Feed errors or warnings
• Products with low-quality images
• Missing descriptions or incomplete attributes
• Price competitiveness alerts

Fix high-priority items flagged by Merchant Center.

2. Enhance Product Titles (30 minutes)

Google AI Mode reads titles conversationally. Update your top 10 products:

❌ "Men's Boot - Black - Size 10" ✅ "Waterproof Hiking Boots for Men - Insulated Winter Trail Boot - Black Leather"

Include: Product type, key features, use case, material, color.

3. Add Rich Descriptions (45 minutes)

AI Mode surfaces products based on description relevance. Write 150-200 word descriptions for top products:

• What is it?
• Who is it for?
• What problems does it solve?
• Key features and benefits
• Use case scenarios

4. Optimize Product Images (30 minutes)

If you sell apparel or visually-driven products:

• Add lifestyle images showing product in use
• Include multiple angles
• Use high-resolution (minimum 800x800px)
• Add model photos for virtual try-on eligibility

Bonus: Enable Performance Max

If you want paid visibility, launch a Performance Max campaign. Google's AI will optimize across Search, Shopping, YouTube, and Display.

---

ChatGPT Shopping Quick Wins (2-3 hours)

1. Add Structured Data (45 minutes)

ChatGPT relies heavily on schema.org markup. Add Product schema to your top 10 products.

Focus on: name, description, brand, price, availability, reviews.

2. Write Conversational Descriptions (60 minutes)

ChatGPT surfaces products when users ask questions. Write descriptions that answer questions:

Instead of feature lists, write:

• "Perfect for winter hiking in cold climates with waterproof construction..."
• "Designed for trail runners who need lightweight support..."
• "Ideal for professionals who spend 8+ hours on their feet..."

Think: What questions do customers ask before buying this product?

3. Optimize for Bing (20 minutes)

ChatGPT uses Bing for product discovery. Check your products in Bing:

• Search for your top products by name
• Verify they're indexed
• Check if product pages rank

If not indexed, submit your sitemap to Bing Webmaster Tools.

4. Apply for Instant Checkout (10 minutes)

If you're on Shopify or Etsy:

• Visit chatgpt.com/merchants
• Fill out merchant application
• Connect your Stripe account (if Shopify)

Instant Checkout availability gives ranking boost in ChatGPT Shopping results.

5. Monitor ChatGPT Traffic (5 minutes)

Set up tracking in Google Analytics 4:

• Look for referral traffic from chatgpt.com
• Check utm_source=chatgpt.com parameter
• Track conversion rates vs. other channels

Early data shows ChatGPT traffic converts at higher rates but lower volume than Google.

---

Long-Term Strategy: The 3-Month Roadmap

Month 1: Establish Presence

• Complete both platform optimizations
• Track baseline performance
• Identify which platform sends better-quality traffic for YOUR products

Month 2-3: Double Down

• Expand product coverage on higher-performing platform
• Test different product categories
• Analyze conversion rate differences
• Adjust strategy based on data

Month 4+: Advanced Optimization

• Build platform-specific product strategies
• Create dedicated landing pages for each platform
• A/B test descriptions and pricing
• Scale what works

The AI shopping war isn't winner-take-all. Both platforms serve different customer behaviors. Google owns browsing and inspiration shopping. ChatGPT owns research and decision shopping.

Smart merchants aren't choosing sides. They're optimizing for both with strategic product selection.

The first-mover window is open for 3-6 months. Early optimizers are building AI visibility while competitors debate which platform matters. By the time tools exist and agencies offer packages, the competitive advantage will be gone.

This week, take 6-8 hours and establish presence on both platforms. Start with the platform that matches your product type. Expand to both within 30 days.

The merchants who act this week won't be fighting for scraps in 2026. They'll be the recommendations ChatGPT and Google AI learned to trust.

Which will you be?